Topic
Fair & Transparent Pricing
94.3% positiveAcross 999 reviews of Fenwick Home Services in St. Augustine, FL, fair & transparent pricing appears in 53 reviews (94.3% positive), from 2016-12-27 through 2026-03-06.
Key findings
Fair & Transparent Pricing mentioned in 53 of 999 reviews (5.3%)
94.3% of Fair & Transparent Pricing reviews are 4 or 5 stars
Average rating in Fair & Transparent Pricing reviews: 4.8★
Aspects most discussed in these reviews
Pricing & Value
100%53 mentionsProfessionalism & Conduct
75%40 mentionsTechnical Knowledge & Expertise
72%38 mentionsProblem Resolution & Effectiveness
45%24 mentionsCommunication & Updates
42%22 mentionsPunctuality & On-Time Service
38%20 mentions
Reviews mentioning fair & transparent pricing
Camper Special
Andrew m was my tech. He installed my new sink fixture quick and good. He was also on time at 12pm on a saterday. Andrew also could have upcharged me but figured out how to do job without all the extra stuff. Thx buddy!!
Response from owner
February 23, 2026
Pamela Walker
Plumbing services, Andrew is professional and offered options for addressing our problem. He provided up front pricing transparency for each option. Work areas were left clean and tidy.
Response from owner
February 23, 2026
BCrown_973
Tim came out to repair a broken pipe in our yard. He identified the issue immediately and gave us the price upfront. The repair was done faster than I expected. I was pleasantly surprised
Response from owner
February 16, 2026
Allison Smith
The service was quick prompt, and the price was reasonable. I showed the technician where I was having an issue and he quickly told me what he could do and how much it would cost me. I would recommend this company again as well as I would use them again.
Response from owner
February 10, 2026
SHAWN FERRIS
We walked through the repairs and I was given an itemized invoice before repairs were started. They were courteous and friendly.
Response from owner
February 5, 2026
Chris Weller
Fenwick plumbing diagnosed my shower issue quickly and gave me estimates on options and fixed on the spot. No hard sell for more work than necessary. Guys were great! Highly recommend
Response from owner
January 12, 2026
Antonio Marshall
Deazion Applebee's represented his craft and company well. I will definitely rely on the services Fenwick has to offer. The prices are fair and out competed two other companies i called.
Response from owner
December 22, 2025
michelle smithers
He was wonderful, very professional very understanding he didn't gouge me price wise I will definitely use them again if I have any other issues definitely five stars
Response from owner
September 29, 2025
Diane Ellsworth
Dan was great. He gave me several options and price points to fix the problem and his unbiased opinion on what would be best for our situation. This resulted in me saving money and not doing more than necessary to fix the problem. I highly recommend Fenwick Home Services.
Response from owner
September 18, 2025
Geoffrey Geytenbeek
Technicians arrive on time and demonstrate both Professionalism and Technical Expertise. They also do not try to “nickel and dime” and overcharge customers
Response from owner
September 2, 2025
Pepe D
I called and set up repair same day James came out right when he said he would the work was done right at a fair price I could not be more pleased. I will call for my next repair
Response from owner
August 28, 2025
Phyllis Gillis
Excellent service! Replacement was done the same day as my estimate! I recommend Fenwick for their services! I used them in the past. They try their best to give you the best price for your money. I purchased a 50 gallon water heater A.O. Smith brand due to the fact my water heater was 19 years old and it reduced my home owners insurance a lot! Our service tech Fahid was very professional. Did his job quickly and efficiently.
Response from owner
August 21, 2025
Angela Lee
Nathan communicated well, showed up on time, was professional and open about the estimate. He went over all discounts that would apply for us. Outdoor faucet replacement was completed in a timely manner and site was cleaned up.
Response from owner
August 21, 2025
Ashley S
Austin was great! He answered all of my questions and gave a full run down of what he was doing and future expectations with a price breakdown. Would recommend!
Response from owner
August 15, 2025
Bill Van Riper III
Adam, the HVAC technician arrived within the promised time window and diagnosed the problem quickly. He ensured all settings were correct and got my air conditioning system running to cool my home again. No hard sell, but only a suggestion to replace a part that may fail. The charge for today’s service was very reasonable. I will use Fenwick/Waychoff for future service when needed.
Response from owner
August 14, 2025
Gordon Shayne
Rodney was on-time, polite & professional, and a very pleasant person. This was our 6 month HVAC check-up which we ourchased last year and will continue to maintain at a great price!! Thank you!
Response from owner
August 11, 2025
Linda Marshall
Justin did a great job. He identified the problem and he didn’t overcharge us by making up work that didn’t need to be done. I appreciate his integrity and workmanship.
Response from owner
August 11, 2025
Charles Hollis
My assigned technician Larry was on time and quickly diagnosed my system for a very reasonable price. Another company arranged through my property manager quoted an 8k system replacement or 4k repair on my unit which is only 7 years. Thank you Fenwick for having honest reliable service technicians who are not trying to rob you for a common defrost sensor repair.
Response from owner
August 11, 2025
Vivian Franklin-Tillman
Technician was very professional and knowledgeable. He identified why my AC unit was not working properly and efficiently replaced the part. This company is fair and honest!
Response from owner
July 7, 2025
Martha Bouse
Scott was amazing. He diagnosed the issue with low water pressure in the house, realized it was a St. Johns County Utilities problem. SJCU showed up and took the issue head on. We will use Fenwick for our plumbing issues from now on. Thank you Scott, and thanks to Fenwick for such fast, dedicated service without breaking the wallet.
Response from owner
July 7, 2025
Marie Carter
I had water leak called them and they came out on Saturday didn't charge me anything extra nothing hidden and Zach was amazing he didn't make any judgment based on prior work he checked everything out and found the leak and took care of it then went above and closed the whole fire me cleaned up and repiped under my sink all for a very reasonable price!!! I will use them from now on with any issue in my home thank you Fenwick and Zach
Response from owner
June 30, 2025
Breanne Abbott
The technician was great. He was able to fix the kitchen faucet in a timely manner. He was very nice and courteous. I was very happy the cost of service was lower than expected. I would definitely recommend the company.
Response from owner
June 30, 2025
John Dunlap
Nathan arrived on time and diagnosed my problem within minutes. He was personable and professional. Did not try to sell me something I did not need, but did give me estimates for possible future purchases that I inquired about. Would highly recommend Fenwick. J Dunlap LCDR, USN, RET
Response from owner
May 26, 2025
Lynda Martin
I want to highly recommend Ron Ayers, Fenwick Service Plumbing Technician, for his excellent work in analyzing my plumbing problem and correcting it in a professional way, He pre-explained the cost of the repair and answered any questions. I rate him A+!
Response from owner
June 13, 2025
Scott George
Ron A. was polite, professional and very informative. I could tell the prices are set at corporate without him saying a word but just clicking on his tablet, however he did what he could to provide corporate provided coupons to make it a reasonable for corporate, him and me given the scope of the project. Ron A was great overall.
Response from owner
May 22, 2025
HENRY REITZEL
This is the fourth job I have had Fenwick service at my home. All of their Associates have been nothing short of fantastic! Most recently, Jesus came out to service my A/C units. This is the best Service Tech I have had at my home. He represents himself and Fenwick in an outstanding way! In addition, Fenwick's rates for A/C maintenance have kept me at the same rate I was paying with a previous provider from 2006! Thanks for the great service and A/C pricing!
Response from owner
May 18, 2025
Cheyenne Overby
I had a great experience with Fenway! They helped me with a last minute appointment after my unit shut off overnight. The tech arrived at the beginning of the appointment and had to crawl out of my window at one point to get to the main unit and did it with a smile on his face. He fixed my issue for $188 after a different company quoted me almost $6K for the exact same issue about 6 months ago. Professional, knowledgeable and so helpful!
Response from owner
December 16, 2024
John Snowden
Cody was on time ready to work. Pricing was clear and all questions were answered. We was done very cleanly with little disruption to our daily activities. Cody was a great representative
Response from owner
May 1, 2025
Paul Franks
I could not recommend Fenwick Plumbing more. They had two crews here today to do a re plumb but determined where we had a leak, fixed it and on the way saving us considerable money. The team was terrific to work with.
Response from owner
May 1, 2025
Luis Garcia
The technician was very cordially explaining the condition of the air conditioner. She conducted all the check outs and tested the components of the air system. Took his time to show with pictures what was necessary to replace. He did not express any pressure and quick decisions to have the air condition running better, only the options of replacing some parts. Gave me the cost of each option well descriptive on his tablet. I was satisfied with the work he did showing good experience on the job. The company FENWICK is very reliable with this type of technicians
Response from owner
April 25, 2024
Anne Jacobs
Fenwick was able to send someone right out to fix our hot water heater. Rafael was wonderful and upfront about pricing. We will be using them again!
Response from owner
April 14, 2025
Zoran Stupar
Worst customer service, no detail on pricing. When the tech arrived there, basically just assess the situation and couldn't do the job. You guys have wonderful ratings, but I'm not sure for what. And then I was charged $89 for just looking Would not use fenvik home services. In the future
Response from owner
April 9, 2025
Nancy Burdett
OMG! Jesse Thigpen was amazing! Called Fenwick this morning and Jesse came out and new hot water heater in within 2 hours of us agreeing to price. I can also tell you that Fenwick beat Home Depot price. Fenwick and Jesse will be my go to for any plumbing issues!! 5 stars!! Thank you Jesse ❤️
Response from owner
March 27, 2025
Colleen Cockcroft
Khan at Fenwick plumbing was super awesome! He was able to find some discounts for me and fixed the blockage in my shower drain without having to bring out the “big guns” which also kept the cost down. Super professional and friendly and explained everything he was doing and picked up on another problem I will need to get onto at some point with my sink tap. Very happy with my experience!
Response from owner
March 18, 2025
Michael Reeve
After determining that my pipes were clogged, I tried to fix on my own with a plunger and ended up pushing the clog and taking down my other bathroom. Made the decision to call a professional. My first initial call was to another company but they charged $200 just to come diagnose what I already knew the problem was. Fenwick was my second choice and will my future first choice. Fenwick only charged an $89 diagnostic fee and were quick to arrive between the scheduled time frame. Rafael showed up and was knowledgeable and very thorough. He was very tidy and after the work was completed he put everything back the way it was previously. As I was over his shoulder, he explained the entire process. Would 10/10 recommend this company to anyone who asks, I have already shared my experience within our neighborhood group.
Response from owner
March 10, 2025
Adele Lawless
Called and asked for a quote on phone, was refused, and said someone had to come out Forced to pay $89 to have someone quote me over $1000 to install a dishwasher $551 (in case you need a quote) - and that was "discounted for me" down from $750, replace a bathtub overflow plate -over $300 (in case you need that quote) and snake a drain over $250 (in case you need that quote), which the stopper was pulled and was left out and not replaced. I paid the ransom fee and sent them away. Handyman is coming to do dishwasher tomorrow for $300. I snaked my own drain with one of those $10 spikey zips from.Home Depot 5 minutes after he left, and another plumber is doing the overflow plate for half of what was quoted for that repair tomorrow as well. What a shame. Longtime customer. Won't return. It cost me $89 to learn that this company went from being my go-to over the years, to crooks.
Response from owner
February 25, 2025
Jackie L
Tim A. W/ the Jax Branch came out and cleared stubborn clogs from old vents/ drains that would have been much more costly if he had not been persistent enough to try alternatives. Tim is very knowledgeable with many years experience and knew the best way to handle each situation. The price was very reasonable and i will call Fenwick again when the time comes. Thank you Tim and Fenwick!
Response from owner
February 12, 2025
vicki newsome
Tech explained different solutions to my problem of a clogged drain, then gave me the total price options. The solution to the problem was too expensive to be able to complete right now. He tried the less expensive route, but that didn’t work, so I paid for the service call and his time, which was fine. I really appreciate him being up front with cost, etc.
Response from owner
February 5, 2025
Albert Ganzemuller
We were taken advantage of from a Jacksonville company when we needed help. DO NOT use this company for any plumbing, cooling or heating needs even if it’s an emergency. Please read the following: We called FENWICK for assistance with our HVAC. During a recent cold snap our HVAC system froze and required immediate attention. A technician arrived and said he couldn’t work on the system until it was defrosted. If it wasn’t frosted that night, he wasn’t sure when he or any other associate could return. He said it would cost $188.00 to defrost the system. For over an hour the associate and I, in freezing temperatures, late in the evening, using hot water from our bathroom tub and our buckets, defrosted the unit. He diagnosed the problem and said we needed a Heat Pump Defroster Sensor. (part number: HH18HA279). The part had to be ordered and would take 5 to 7 days and the part would cost $441.00. Installation could take another 5 to 7 days. FENWICK charged us $89.00 for the service visit and $188.00 to defrost the unit. The part was installed about a week later. While waiting for the part I went to their web site and found that 3 coupons were available but were not offered. We asked the technician why he didn’t offer the coupons to which he replied “that’s up to you”. I took a photo of the part number and found that the part was sold by FACTORY AUTHORIZED PARTS. I found the part on-line for $31.00 and that it was available from Amazon and could be delivered free the next day. The final cost was $490.00 for the installation of a $31.00 part. After questioning the cost, FENWICK offered to waive the $89.00 service fee and offered to honor the coupons we found on-line from their web site. Our final cost was $530.00 ($342.00 plus $188.00) for the service call. Caveat Emptor!
Response from owner
February 4, 2025
Barry Bort
Matt and Paul are very professional. Stuck to problem until resolved. Took off their footwear prior to entering the house on multiple occasions. Were insistent on cleaning up all areas inside and out. Did not waste time in any point in a 3 hour process. I will only use Fenwick from now on for plumbing issues. Saved me at least $3,000 based on an alternate assessment of the problem.
Response from owner
January 24, 2025
North Florida Baseball Academy Jacksonville, FL
Wealth of information and experience. Laid out every choice. I had 3 choices. No hard sell. Knowledge is power and I felt that I decided on the best choice within my budget. Yes... I would definitely tell a family member or friend to give them a call. Btw, the company has an AC division and same company installed my new AC unit... 5 stars as well.
Response from owner
January 13, 2025
Jade McBroom
We have used Fenwick for years! Always pleased every time and have recommended them to friends and family who have also become satisfied customers. Our most recent service tech, Andrew M., was on time, professional and did an excellent job explaining what he would be doing and the cost. Greatly appreciated.
Response from owner
December 23, 2024
Rob
We are beyond pleased and impressed with Fenwick Plumbing. We had an urgent need for service, and within an hour, a technician arrived. Zach quickly assessed the situation, explained the necessary repairs, and resolved the issue within 10 minutes. The professionalism and rapid response time were by far the best we've ever experienced. The rates were reasonable, and we now know that, should we ever need a plumber again, Fenwick will be our go-to for life.
Response from owner
December 2, 2024
Kyle Hulcher
We were having toilet issues, so we reached out to a plumber service. That plumber service felt like it was overpricing us. We decided then to reach out to Fenwick Home Services. When John Matthew Atnip showed up to our door, there was an immediate difference. Matthew was both charismatic and professional. He immediately ascertained the issue with our toilet and proceeded to thoroughly check the rest of our house’s plumbing. The pricing was fair and based on Matthew’s professionalism, we knew we were receiving excellent service. Next time we have a plumbing issue, we will not hesitate to reach out to Fenwick Home Services first.
Response from owner
October 24, 2024
Katherine Johnson
Jesse did a great job with our water heater replacement. Everything was as promised and he made sure to explain everything from warranty to instructions for making adjustments and future service. No surprises on pricing either. Highly recommend,
Response from owner
October 22, 2024
C Singstock
I had 4 water heater installation estimates with 4 different companies and Fenwick price was several hundred dollars less and included everything. They did not pressure me and when I chose them to do the installation. They came the next day and were prompt. The technician, Andrew, was professional, efficient and experienced. Highly recommend for water heater installation...haven't used their other services.
Response from owner
October 18, 2024
Natalie Urquhart
Highly recommend Fenwick. Our AC compressor went out and we required a whole new system. They were able to come out same day give us an estimate and replace next day within 5 hours. They even matched a quote I received previously and did more work than the other company stated they would. Cannot recommend Fenwick enough!
Response from owner
September 5, 2024
Lorna Foster
Thank goodness for Jesse who arrived early to take care of an emergency plumbing issue. He spoke in terms I could understand and explained how the issue developed. After a thorough investigation, Jesse repaired the malfunction. I feel so fortunate that he answered the call. Pricing was fair, especially since the outcome could have been worse. Thank you Fenwick!
Response from owner
August 29, 2024
Scott M
I have an older house built in the 60s with cast iron pipes. Needed to get a home inspection asap to change homeowners insurance after many home insurance companies bailed out of business in FL. The main issue was a clog in a bathroom sink along with polybutylene pea traps that had been previously installed at my house. I decided to obtain 3 estimates. Fenwick sent Joshua S. out to provide initial estimate, diagnostic work, and repair. I am 100% certain that Fenwick saved me hundreds of dollars on the cut out and repair of defective piping within a shared wall between kitchen and bath sink. Joshua noticed that he could access faulty bath sink drain piping through a panel under the kitchen sink. A competitor wanted to rip out my bathroom tile, wall, etc. to access the pipe. Professional, reasonable, smart, and fast is how I'd like to describe Fenwick Home Services. I now know who to call when I need plumbing in the future. Thank you, Fenwick!
Response from owner
August 1, 2024
Will Ludwigsen
Fenwick is fast, capable, and honest. A plumber from another company arrived late to look at our hot water heater, poked at the pilot light, and then pitched us a $4,100 replacement. I called Fenwick the next day and their tech arrived on time, cleared out some dust, performed some much-needed maintenance, and charged me $149 for a standard service call. They are my new best friends.
Response from owner
July 1, 2024
Kevin Owens
Technician, Christian, arrived on time and went right to work doing an inspection, testing, and cleaning of my AC system. He was very thorough, quick, and friendly. The special pricing advertised for this inspection was very good and there was no cutting corners. Very pleased with the service from Fenwick. Great communications as well. Highly recommend using Fenwick for installation (they installed my system 3 years ago at a very competitive price) and for servicing your existing system.
Response from owner
February 22, 2024
Richard Sentz
We placed a service call on Tuesday morning and were informed that a technician could arrive before noon, which was faster than we had expected. Tim Allala was the service technician who arrived and he provided excellent service. He was able to resolve the issue in a timely and efficient manner. The quote provided was more than fair. We will definitely keep Fenwick in mind as our go-to in the future. Thank you, on behalf of Gordon Chevrolet of Orange Park!
Response from owner
November 16, 2023
Garrett Kingsbury
Overall, great experience with Fenwick. First time ever having to call a plumber. Did some routine checking on my end unit I needed some professional advice. I called Fenwick around 2PM and they were able to send someone out same-day for a leak in our guest bathroom. Ron was great. Professional, experienced, and didn’t mind me asking some questions while occasionally watching him survey the issue. He chatted through options, ideas, and even taught me a thing or two along the way. After about 2 hours from start to finish, Ron fixed our issue, gave me his card, and now we’ve developed a trusting relationship with Fenwick. Out the door price was cheaper than I expected, which was fantastic. I’ll be using them again if we ever need a plumber in the future (knock on wood we won’t).
Response from owner
June 27, 2023